What's The Best Crib Mattress For Your Baby? 

In this post, our mission is to help you find the best crib mattress available in 2017. They are one of the most important purchases for your child. A high-quality mattress provides a safe surface for your child to sleep on. Poor-quality models are likely to break quickly and may even be unsafe.

Many new parents are surprised by the range of crib options available. Every manufacture claims that have the safest crib mattress. This can make it difficult to choose the best option for your budget.


The main factors when choosing are the type of mattress, price, firmness and thickness. Your budget is also an important consideration – the most expensive often come with a range of additional features that you might not need.

We want to reduce your stress when it comes to making a buying decision. Our crib mattress reviews consider all the main buying factors – including how to choose the best option for your child’s age. We’ve also compiled a list of the top three crib mattresses. Each of these products has been highly rated by parents and provides great value.

Our Buyer's Guide

There are two primary purposes of crib mattresses: to be both supportive and safe for your child. While many have additional features, such as being hypoallergenic, durable or stain resistant, your main goal should be to find the safest baby mattress.

Material Type

The two most common types of crib mattresses are spring and foam. Neither type is always “better,” although there are some differences between the two. Here’s an overview of the positives and negatives with each style.

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress material
  • Spring. A spring style supports the child via an array of inner springs. In most cases, the more springs a product has, the firmer it will be. The firmness also depends on the gauge of coil used – a lower gauge means a thicker and firmer spring. Spring mattresses are usually more durable but are also more expensive.
  • Foam. Foam models are usually cheaper. They don’t contain any springs, so the firmness depends on the density of the foam. Denser foam is also more durable. Foam models tend to be lighter than spring, which makes them easier to remove from the crib. This also makes them more suitable for portable styles.
  • Organic. Organic cribs have risen in popularity over the past few years. Many parents choose organic becuase it eliminates the use of chemicals that could potentially harm you baby. If you’re interested in this option, be sure to read our organic crib buyer’s guide.

Age of the Child

The age of your child can affect the mattress you should buy. For toddlers, a softer product may be the best choice. Softer versions provide a more relaxing night’s sleep with fewer interruptions.

In contrast, a baby’s crib mattress should always be firm to reduce the chances of suffocation. When buying one, do not choose a product that has been designed for an older child. While a firmer model can sometimes feel uncomfortable to the parent, they provide the support and safety a baby needs.


Expensive models are usually firmer with either greater foam density or more springs. This isn’t always the case though – sometimes a manufacturer charges more because their product has extra features. It’s important to look at both the features and reviews before judging its value for money.

In most cases, you don’t need to spend hundreds of dollars on this type of baby bed, which can usually provide the quality and features required by most parents.

Your budget also affects the type that you should buy. If you have a small budget, it’s usually best to choose a foam option. The cheapest are often low-quality and noisy, which can cause disturbed sleep for both you and your baby. It’s almost impossible to relax if you can hear your child’s every movement.

Other Considerations

  • Quality. Higher prices don’t always mean increased quality, but you should avoid poor quality mattresses. These are likely to be built with weak covers that crack or tear easily.
  • Thickness. The thickness can affect its comfort and firmness. A crib mattress shouldn’t be thicker than 6”.
  • Waterproof. It’s always a good idea to use a protector to prevent liquid from entering the mattress. Protectors may not stop all liquid though, so it’s important to choose one that is waterproof.
  • Warranty. You shouldn’t be too concerned by warranties. A high-quality baby crib should last a lot longer than you need it for. While most have a 10 or even 20 year warranty, this is usually a marketing device rather than an essential feature.

Top 3 - Crib Mattress Review

1. Sealy Soybean Foam-Core

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress

The Sealy Soybean is a foam mattress that is manufactured using American soybean oils. It is designed to be comfortable yet firm, and also includes a waterproof cover.

The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core crib mattress has received a Greenguard Gold Certification. This indicates that it has been made from materials that are safe for children to sleep on.

The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core is one of the top rated crib mattresses.Most of the buyers say that it is built with 1.5lb density foam, which provides enough firmness to be safe for young children. Some people write that they are impressed with the value and comfort considering the low price.

A few of them feel that the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core isn’t comfortable enough for their child. While it may be too firm for older children, it is great for younger children or babies.

2. Dream On Me Spring

The Dream On Me Spring Crib is a popular option that provides a comfortable and firm sleeping surface. It’s a lightweight model that is built with 88 internal coils. It is designed to resist stains and is also hypoallergenic.

Reviews of the Dream On Me Crib have been very positive. Many of them say that it is comfortable, provides great value and that their toddlers enjoy sleeping on it.

Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler

Many people find that it fitted the crib perfectly, appears to be durable, and also that the quality is higher than he expected for the price.

Parents write that the Dream On Me Crib is an excellent choice for a toddler or young child. It probably isn’t firm enough for a baby though. If you’re searching for a product for your baby, look for an option with lower gauge springs for increased firmness.

3. Sealy Baby Firm Rest

Sealy Baby Firm Rest

The Sealy Baby Firm Rest is an excellent option if you’re looking for a firm, high-quality mattress. It is built with 204 steel coils and has passed the Greenguard certification for baby health. It also comes with a waterproof cover to prevent stains – a useful feature for young children.

While it’s number three on our list, many parents feel the Sealy is the best baby mattress on the market.

Reviewers have been impressed by the comfort and firmness of the Sealy Baby Firm Rest. Most of them write that they found it to be firm, relatively lightweight and easy to clean.

A problem with the Sealy Baby Firm Rest is that it can develop an indentation after being used for a while. This doesn’t seem to always happen – some reviewers report that they haven’t had an issue with indentations – but it is something to keep in mind.


Baby and toddler equipment can be expensive, so it’s important to find products that provide value for money. Crib mattresses, however, are an item where it pays to spend a bit more. A high-quality crib model can help your entire family sleep better. It can also ensure your baby’s safety when sleeping.


The most important consideration when choosing a foam mattress is firmness. Babies should always sleep on a firm surface, as this reduces the chances of suffocation. Older children may prefer a softer version for a more comfortable night’s sleep. Firmness depends on the number of coils and coil gauge for spring mattresses, and the density of foam.

Another factor is the type of crib. Foam models tend to be cheaper and lighter, but are usually not recommended for long-term use. Spring mattresses are durable but also cost more. It’s important to consider both your requirements and budget when deciding which type to buy. For smaller budgets, it’s usually best to choose a foam mattress, while for long-term use a spring style is recommended.

If you’re not sure which to buy, we recommend the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core. It’s a high-quality product that is both firm and reasonably priced. The fact that it has a Greenguard Gold Certification also means that it’s guaranteed to be healthy for your child to sleep on.

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required

Pin It on Pinterest