What's The Best Goose Down Comforter in 2017?

If you’re searching for a soft and warm comforter, goose down could be the perfect option. It is often considered to be the ultimate in bedroom luxury, as it provides exceptional comfort and fluffiness. The soft nature of goose down feathers also means that you won’t feel the individual quills while sleeping – a common problem with inferior feathers.

The expensive price of this type of comforter can make choosing the best product difficult.

It’s important to find a product that is durable, comfortable and doesn’t cause you to overheat – yet still matches your budget. Factors such as the stitch quality – which prevents the feathers from bunching – and fabric type are also important.

Some comforters are made with 100% goose down feathers. These are the highest quality and also most expensive. Other products are made from a mixture of feathers – often including polyester. These are cheaper, but tend to be less dense and heavy. There are also options made from synthetic “alternatives” – which don’t provide the same level of comfort and luxury but are considerably cheaper.

Pinzon Signature Pyrenees Hypoallergenic Medium Warmth White Goose Down Comforter

After reviewing all the top goose down comforter available, we’ve selected our top 7 picks in the comparison table below. We’re confident you’ll find the perfect model for your needs.

Comparison Table

Mobile Users : For optimal viewing, tilt your phone to landscape (wide-view) to see the entire table.

Aside from the filler, it’s important to get a comforter that you enjoy sleeping with. The thickness is an important factor as it affects heat retention. If you live in a warm climate, a thick comforter may be uncomfortably hot for most of the year. You should also be aware of the fill power before you buy. This is a measure of how dense the filler is, and affects both the weight and heat of the product.

If you’ve decided to buy a goose down comforter, this article is designed to make choosing as simple as possible. We’ve searched the internet for the top rated products in this category and reviewed them below. Each of the four products in this article has received excellent reviews from buyers – which is one of the most reliable indicators of quality.

Top Four Rated Goose Down Comforters

1. Pinzon Signature Pyrenees Hypoallergenic

The Pinzon Signature Pyrenees is designed to keep you cool in the summer and warm in the winter. If you’re looking for a comforter you can use throughout the year, this is one of the best options.

It comes with a 100% cotton cover for smooth and warm comfort, and has a 600 fill power for medium weight and warmth. The product is also built with a baffle box design – which prevents the filler from moving around or bunching up.

Some of the reviewers say that it’s a fantastic product that keeps them at a comfortable temperature throughout the night. Most of them state that it has an even fill – something that cannot be said about low-quality alternatives.

The size of the comforter is a potential downside mentioned by some reviewers. A few of them say that it’s an excellent product – but that it doesn’t overlap the end of the bed by much, even if you buy the correct size. Despite this, it’s still one of the best value goose down comforters on the market.

2. Supremium Baffle Box Medium Weight Hungarian

The Supremium Hungarian Goose Down Comforter is built for luxury, with a 700 fill power and high-quality cover. It’s a medium warmth product that’s suitable for any season, and has a baffle box construction to stop the filler moving. The shell is 100% cotton and hypoallergenic, making the product suitable for those with allergies.

Several reviewers mention that the Supremium is the best quality down product. Many of them said that it provides exceptional value compared to those they saw in retail stores, and that the Hungarian feathers provide extra comfort compared with those from other locations.

Most of the reviewers say that the product is worth every penny. They mention that it provides the most comfortable sleep they ever had and that it’s also relatively light.

Like the Pinzon Signature above, several reviewers write that the Supremium is slightly smaller than they hoped. This isn’t a major issue – the size difference is marginal – but is something to keep in mind before buying.

3. 1200 Thread Count King 1200TC Siberian

If you’re searching for a fluffy and soft comforter that’s also relatively cheap, this could be the perfect option. The 750+ fill power is at the high end of goose down comforters, and provides greater fluffiness and warmth. It also comes with a 1200 thread cotton cover that’s both hypoallergenic and smooth to sleep on.

Reviewers say that it keeps them warm even during cold winter weather. Most of them mention that it is relatively light considering the warmth and high fill power.

There was a period several years ago when this product received a number of poor reviews from buyers. It appears that this was due to an issue with manufacturing – the reviewers write that the comforter didn’t match the product description. Fortunately, this seems to have been solved, with the product now receiving rave reviews from buyers.

4. MARRIKAS Summer Weight White

If you want the soft feel of goose down but without the warm temperatures, the MARRIKAS could be the perfect option. It has a relatively low 550 fill power which keeps it lightweight and cool compared to alternatives. The 100% cotton cover finishes off the luxury feel of the MARRIKAS.

Reviewers write that the MARRIKAS is a great choice if you live in a warm climate. People who have bought this said that it’s very comfortable and provides the right level of warmth. Many reviewers say that it’s the perfect size and weight.

When you first buy the MARRIKAS it will probably look thinner than you expected. This is normal – the fluffiness returns to the product when you shake it.

You should also air the product for a few hours before first using it, as this gets rid of any odors left over from the manufacturing process.


Goose down comforters provide the ultimate in luxury bedding. They are soft, warm and fluffy – even compared with duck down alternatives – and can be comfortable to sleep on all year round. While they are more expensive than other options, a high-quality goose down comforter can provide many years of comfort.

There are several considerations when buying a goose down comforter (how to find a new one). Firstly, you need to think about the heat and weight you enjoy from a comforter. Do you want a heavy and warm option? If so, choose a high fill power product. Or are you looking for a summer comforter? In this case, a lighter product with a lower fill power might be the best option.

It’s also important to buy a high-quality product. Look for comforters with 100% goose down feathers. A baffle box construction can also help to prevent the filler material from bunching.

If you’re not sure which to buy, we recommend the Pinzon Signature Pyrenees. It’s available in three sizes, comes with a 100% cotton shell and has “PermaBaffle” construction to prevent the filler from moving. The Pinzon Signature has also received excellent reviews from buyers, so you can be sure that it provides outstanding comfort and warmth.

If you’re looking for more options, read our Down Alternative Comforter article.

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required

Pin It on Pinterest