Best Down Alternative Comforter - 2017 Reviews

In this article, we break down the best down alternative comforters available in 2017. Down feathers are the lushest and most comfortable filler for bedding products. Unfortunately, they can also cost a lot of money! The good news is that there are some excellent down alternative comforters on the market. These provide many of the same benefits as down – including extra warmth and comfort – without the high cost. In some cases, alternative materials can reduce the chances of an allergic reaction and are also easier to wash.

There are some disadvantages to down alternatives, though. Firstly, alternatives tend to be heavier. If you enjoy sleeping with lighter bedding materials, make sure you look for a comforter that’s lightweight and doesn’t feel restrictive to sleep with.

Another potential problem is the warmth of alternative materials. They are usually not as warm as true down feathers, as synthetic material isn’t as effective at absorbing heat. This doesn’t mean you can’t find a warm down alternative comforter though – there are some excellent products on the market – but you need to be careful to pick a product that provides the warmth you require.

After reviewing all the top down alternative comforter available, we’ve selected our top 7 picks in the comparison table below. We’re confident you’ll find the perfect model for your needs.

image of best down alternative comforter

Our Top Pick – Chezmoi Collection White Goose Down Alternative Comforter

Comparison Table

Mobile Users : For optimal viewing, tilt your phone to landscape (wide-view) to see the entire table.

Top Three Rated Down Alternative Comforters

1. Chezmoi Collection

The Chezmoi Collection comforter/duvet insert (one of the best comforter ever) is designed to maintain a cozy temperature all year round. It features a box stitched design, which prevents the filler from moving, and has corner tabs to fix the cover in place. A bonus is that the product is 100% hypoallergenic, as it’s made with synthetic fibers.

Many reviewers are surprised by the quality of the product considering the relatively low price. Most of the buyers say that it provides exceptional value and is both soft and puffy. Some reviewers mention that it provides “cloud-like” comfort.

The size of the product (you can also try best king size comforters) may be slightly smaller than you would expect. The full dimensions are listed with the product, so it’s a good idea to check these against the cover before you buy. Considering the low price, we still think the Chezmoi is one of the best rated options available.

2. Grand Down All Season

The Grand Down All Season (one of the best selling comforters) provides a warm – but not too hot – night’s sleep and is suitable for any season. It’s built with a synthetic microfiber that provides a soft and comfortable night’s sleep. The product is also hypoallergenic.

This kind of comforter (bed comforter) is one of the top rated down alternative comforters on the market. Most of the reviewers say that it has exceeded their expectations and provides exceptional value. Some say that it’s the perfect thickness and density to keep them at the right temperature for all weather.

Unlike true down comforters (high end down comforters), the Grand Down All Season isn’t extra fluffy. It still provides warmth and a comfortable night’s sleep – but if you love the fluffy feel of feathers then it probably isn’t the best option.

3. Natural Comfort Classic Heavy Fill White

The Natural Comfort Classic is a high-quality product that comes with a 100% cotton, 200 thread-count cover. It features a piped edge and 7” stitching box to prevent the filler from moving. It’s also a heavy fill comforter, meaning that it’s warm and fluffy – but may not be suitable for hotter climates.

A lot of the reviewers state that the Natural Comfort Classic is warm even in the coldest weather. They mention that it doesn’t feel heavy but provides the heat retention you need when living in colder climates. Majority of them write that it provides great value and is surprisingly for a down alternative blanket.

If you live in a cold climate, or if you’re searching for a good and warm winter comforter, then the Natural Comfort Classic is a great option. Reviewers write that it’s not the softest as compared to true down products, but this is to be expected from a synthetic material. There are few comforters in this price range that can provide the same level of warmth and comfort.


Not all comforters are the same. There isn’t yet a man-made material that can match the warmth of down feathers. Even so, down alternatives (best cheap down comforters) provide many of the same advantages – without the high cost. If you love the warmth of down feathers but don’t have a large budget, or if you suffer from allergies (it is advisable for you to use washable down comforters), they can be an excellent choice.

Choosing the best one depends on your personal requirements. Your local climate is one of the most important factors. Thicker down comforter sets are great for winter or cooler climates – but can be excessively hot in warm weather. The fill power also affects the weight and heat retention of a product.

Due to the range of different materials used, it’s important to read reviews. The best products are fluffy, durable, and feel both light and warm to sleep under. Low-quality products are often thin, don’t have the fluffy feel of true down and fail to provide the same warm comfort.

If you’re not sure which to choose, we recommend the Chezmoi Collection Down Alternative Comforter. It’s a luxury product that hits the “sweet spot” between keeping you warm and preventing overheating, and is suitable for almost any climate. It is also designed with box stitching to prevent the filler from moving.

If you’re still not sure, we recommend reading our Goose Down Comforter guide.

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required

Pin It on Pinterest